English at home
Anxious or silent in English lessons: how can I support my child?
Quick answer
Some children cannot speak in certain situations because anxiety makes them freeze, and this is not stubbornness or rudeness. Do not pressure or bribe your child to speak, accept nods and gestures, and praise small steps in private. A GP or speech and language therapist can look at what is going on; an English lesson cannot.
Some children chatter at home and then go completely quiet in front of a teacher or on a screen. That can be heartbreaking to watch, and it can feel confusing. This guide explains what the NHS says about anxiety around speaking and selective mutism, how to take the pressure off in English lessons and when to ask a professional.
- By CurioKids teamHow we write our guides
- Published
- Updated
- 8 min read
Key takeaways
- The NHS describes selective mutism as an anxiety disorder in which a child cannot speak in certain social situations, though they can speak freely with people they know well.
- It is not a choice or a refusal, so pressure and bribes tend to make it harder.
- Accept nodding, pointing and waving until your child is ready for more.
- Praise progress privately rather than in front of others.
- Only a professional can say whether a child has selective mutism; this guide does not diagnose.
On this page
Why might a child go silent in a lesson?
Many children are quiet when they begin a new language. It can help to read about the silent period, which is a normal stage. This guide is about something different: a child who is anxious about speaking, who freezes in some settings even though they want to join in.
A lesson on a screen can add pressure. There is a stranger, a camera, a microphone and an expectation of an answer. Some children feel watched even when only one person is looking. Others fear getting a word wrong in a language that is not their own. Silence in that moment is a way of coping.
What does the NHS say about selective mutism?
The NHS describes selective mutism as an anxiety disorder in which a person cannot speak in particular social situations, such as at school, while they speak freely with close family and friends. It usually starts in early childhood. The NHS stresses that it is not a choice or a refusal: speaking triggers a freeze response.
The NHS also notes that children who are anxious, or who have speech, hearing or sensory processing difficulties, may be more at risk, and that treatment aims to reduce the anxiety around speaking rather than to work on speech itself. Whether your child has selective mutism or is simply shy or new to English is not something a parent or a teacher can decide. Please do not label your child; ask a professional.
What helps, and what does not?
The NHS gives parents these starting points, which suit lessons too:
- Do not pressure or bribe your child to speak. Promising a treat for talking can add to the fear.
- Acknowledge the fear. "It's okay to feel nervous. Small steps are fine."
- Accept non-verbal replies. A nod, a wave, a thumbs-up or pointing at a picture all count.
- Praise in private. A loud "well done for talking!" in front of others can feel like a spotlight.
- Do not avoid every social event, but make them more comfortable, and ask others to give your child time.
Do not ask "why won't you speak?" or finish your child's sentences when you are on a call. Instead, let the teacher wait, and keep your face relaxed.
How can a lesson be set up to feel safer?
- Start with listening only. Ask the teacher to begin with songs, stories and pictures where your child does not have to say anything.
- Offer yes or no and choices. "Red or blue?" can be answered with a point.
- Use a puppet or a toy. Some children will whisper to a toy before they speak to a person.
- Keep the camera comfortable. Ask what your child prefers, and move the screen so they are not looking at their own face.
- Stay close, then step back slowly. Your presence is reassuring at first. Move a little further away only when your child is ready.
A live one-to-one lesson removes the audience of classmates, and a teacher can wait, change the activity and accept any reply. The teacher can adapt pace and activities, but they are an English teacher, not a therapist. Lessons do not treat anxiety or selective mutism.
When should I ask a professional?
The NHS suggests asking a GP for a referral to a specialist service, or contacting a speech and language therapy clinic directly. A school educational psychologist or a mental health professional may be involved if there are other concerns. Ask early if your child is silent in most places outside the home, if it has lasted for weeks or if it is making your child unhappy. Treatment, such as gradual steps with a therapist, is a matter for a professional.
What can I say to my child before and after?
Words from a parent can lift or add weight. Before a lesson, aim to be calm and plain: “You do not have to speak. You can listen, nod or point. I am right here.” That one sentence removes the pressure that makes freezing more likely.
After a lesson, resist the urge to ask “Did you talk?” Ask instead about things your child can answer without having to rate themselves: “What was the story about? Which game was your favourite?” If they spoke, a quiet smile is enough. If they did not, say “I enjoyed sitting with you,” and mean it.
- Avoid: “Why won’t you talk?”, “Say it, the teacher is waiting”, “You were fine at home.”
- Try: “It is okay to be nervous. Small steps are fine.”
- Share a story of a time you felt nervous and what helped you.
- Look after yourself. Watching a child struggle is hard, and talking to a GP, a friend or a support group about your own worry is sensible.
How can I measure progress without pushing?
Look for small, quiet wins: a child who watches the screen for longer, nods in answer, points to the right picture, whispers a word to you or laughs at the teacher's silly voice. Write them in a notebook for yourself. They add up, and they remind you that progress is not only speaking out loud.
Families in Singapore and Malaysia can find the lesson details on their country page, and the FAQ answers common questions.
Be patient with the timeline. Anxiety around speaking can ease slowly, with steps forwards and some back. A child who whispered last week may be silent this week, because they are tired or because something changed. Try not to read too much into a single lesson. What counts over time is that your child keeps feeling safe with the teacher, and that you keep the door open to a professional if worry grows.
Frequently asked questions
Is my child being rude or stubborn when they will not answer?
Almost certainly not. The NHS describes selective mutism as a freeze response triggered by anxiety, not a choice. Even when the cause is shyness, a child who is silent usually feels uncomfortable rather than defiant.
Should I reward my child for speaking in the lesson?
It is better not to offer bribes or rewards for speaking, because they can add to the pressure. Praise effort quietly afterwards, and accept any kind of reply as a success.
Can the teacher diagnose selective mutism?
No. A teacher can tell you how your child behaves in the lesson, but only a health professional can say whether a child has selective mutism. If you are concerned, ask a GP or a speech and language therapist.
Is it better to wait until my child speaks English before booking lessons?
There is no need to wait. A lesson with no pressure to speak can be a gentle way to listen and join in using gestures. If it feels too much, you can stop and try again later.
Sources
- Selective mutism, NHS